Vendor Risk Management (VRM) is a crucial part of any organization's risk management process. It ensures that third-party vendors do not introduce unacceptable risks. In 2024, continuous monitoring has become a key aspect of VRM, focusing on security risks among other various categories of third-party risks.
Emerging vendor risks may go undetected without continuous monitoring, undermining all previous VRM efforts. This article explores the importance of ongoing vendor monitoring, implementation instructions, and best practices to follow.
Take control of your organization’s vendor risk management program with UpGuard >
What is ongoing vendor monitoring in vendor risk management?
Continuous monitoring in vendor risk management involves regularly assessing a vendor's performance, ensuring compliance with regulations, evaluating financial stability, and examining operational resilience. Third-party monitoring is essential for managing the risks associated with third-party relationships.
Ongoing vendor monitoring uses processes like performance metrics, audits, and regular reviews to identify deviations from expected service levels or potential risks, such as cybersecurity threats and data breaches. This active oversight approach allows organizations to quickly address issues, adapt their risk management strategies, and maintain the security and effectiveness of their vendor ecosystem.
Benefits of VRM continuous monitoring
Continuous monitoring in VRM safeguards against potential risks and compliance issues and enhances the overall value derived from vendor relationships, ensuring they contribute positively to the organization's goals.
Continuous monitoring in VRM offers several key benefits:
- Early issue detection: Continuous monitoring helps organizations identify and address potential issues before they become significant problems. By constantly monitoring vendor performance, compliance, and risk indicators, companies can swiftly detect anomalies, such as a drop in service quality or a breach in data security, minimizing their impact and facilitating smoother operations.
- Regulatory compliance: Staying compliant with laws and regulations is crucial for any organization. Continuous monitoring ensures that vendors adhere to requirements, reducing the risk of penalties and reputational damage. It also helps maintain up-to-date documentation and audit trails for regulatory reviews.
- Enhanced performance management: Regular oversight of vendor performance against agreed-upon metrics and standards ensures that vendors consistently meet or exceed expectations, optimizing operational efficiency and strengthening vendor relationships through transparent performance evaluations and feedback.
- Risk mitigation: Continuous monitoring helps identify vendor risks like financial instability, poor security controls, and operational vulnerabilities, allowing companies to implement timely risk mitigation strategies and ensure business continuity.
- Strategic alignment: Continuous assessment of vendors ensures alignment with business objectives, such as Governance, Risk, and Compliance (GRC) or Environmental, Social, & Governance (ESG) goals, which is crucial for long-term success and decision-making.
Integrating continuous monitoring into a vendor’s lifecycle
Integrating continuous monitoring throughout a vendor's lifecycle, from onboarding to offboarding, ensures security teams execute each phase with a focus on managing and mitigating risks. Here's how to effectively integrate continuous monitoring across the vendor lifecycle:
- Onboarding: Conduct vendor risk assessments and due diligence, define metrics and expectations, establish a monitoring framework
- Integration: Perform initial reviews and audits and set up communication channels
- Ongoing management: Implement regular performance evaluation, adapt monitoring tools, and perform compliance checks
- Relationship growth/vendor maturity: Adjust monitoring based on performance along with conducting strategic reviews
- Renewal or offboarding: Conduct a performance review for renewal decisions, implement an offboarding process if the vendor relationship is terminated, and perform post-offboarding monitoring
This lifecycle integration helps maintain compliance, optimize performance, and safeguard against potential issues at every stage.
How often should ongoing monitoring happen in vendor risk management?
The frequency of ongoing vendor risk management (VRM) monitoring depends on several factors, including the nature of the business relationship, risk ratings associated with the vendor, and regulatory requirements. Here’s how you might determine the appropriate monitoring intervals:
- Vendor risk profile: High-risk vendors—those whose failure or breach could significantly impact your organization—should be monitored more frequently. Consider continuous, real-time monitoring for some aspects like cybersecurity risk or monthly to quarterly financial health and service delivery reviews.
- Regulatory requirements: Compliance with relevant regulations may dictate how often you monitor your vendors. For instance, vendors handling personal data may need to be reviewed more frequently due to data protection laws.
- Business impact: Vendors providing critical services or products in the supply chain, especially those directly affecting your core business functions or customer data, require more frequent monitoring. For example, IT service providers that handle sensitive data might need closer scrutiny than a supplier of office supplies.
- Vendor performance and history: Security teams should monitor vendors with a history of security incidents or inconsistent performance more frequently until they demonstrate stable improvement. Conversely, personnel might monitor vendors with a long track record of compliance and strong security posture less frequently, though still regularly.
- Changes in vendor status: Any significant changes in a vendor’s business—like risk criticality, mergers, acquisitions, financial distress, or leadership changes—should trigger more frequent monitoring to assess how these changes affect risk and compliance.
How to get started with vendor ongoing monitoring
Ongoing monitoring of vendors is essential for controlling external risks and ensuring third parties meet compliance and performance standards throughout the relationship's duration. Here’s a step-by-step guide to effectively setting up an ongoing vendor monitoring process.
1. Risk assessment
Before effectively monitoring your vendors, it is essential to understand the specific risks associated with each vendor. To begin, conduct a comprehensive risk assessment that evaluates the following:
- The vendor's financial health
- Compliance with relevant laws and industry standards
- Cybersecurity measures, information security, and data protection practices
- Operational resilience and reliability
- Dependency of your business operations on their services
This assessment will help identify areas requiring close monitoring and determine the frequency of reviews based on the risk levels associated with each vendor.
2. Select monitoring tools
Choosing the right tools and software to support continuous monitoring of the identified risk areas is important. These tools may include:
- Vendor risk management platforms that offer real-time insights and dashboards
- Performance tracking software to monitor SLAs and KPIs
- Compliance tracking workflows to ensure vendors meet all regulatory requirements
- Security monitoring tools, especially for IT vendors, to detect potential data breaches or vulnerabilities
The choice of tools will depend on your specific needs and the areas of risk identified in the initial assessment.
3. Define monitoring criteria
Ensure that you have the necessary tools and define clear criteria for what to monitor and how to report it. Monitoring criteria include:
- Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) to assess vendor performance
- Compliance indicators based on industry and legal standards
- Security metrics, such as incident response times and breach impacts
- Financial indicators like credit scores and liquidity ratios
Set thresholds and alert systems within your monitoring tools to flag any deviations from these criteria, which will help you respond swiftly to potential issues.
4. Implement monitoring processes
Develop and formalize the monitoring program and integrate this program into your VRM program. The monitoring process should include:
- A regular schedule for performance reviews and audits
- Procedures for handling notifications from monitoring tools
- Escalation processes for critical issues and remediation
- Feedback mechanisms to continuously improve and fine-tune the monitoring efforts
Ensure these processes are well-documented and integrated into your overall TPRM program.
5. Train staff
Your staff needs to be well-equipped to carry out ongoing monitoring tasks. Provide comprehensive training that covers:
- How to use selected monitoring tools
- Monitoring criteria and why they are important
- Procedures for incident response
- Communication skills for dealing with vendors regarding performance issues or compliance needs
Consider implementing regular training updates as monitoring tools and processes evolve.
Best practices for continuous monitoring in vendor risk management
Continuous monitoring is essential for managing vendor risks, ensuring that vendors meet contractual obligations, and complying with regulatory standards. Below are the best practices for optimizing vendor risk management through continuous monitoring.
Automating processes
Automating as much of the continuous monitoring process as possible improves efficiency and minimizes human error. By using risk monitoring and alert services, organizations can maintain a consistent overview of their vendor risk profiles.
Utilize software to automatically track performance metrics, compliance data, and risk indicators. Automation tools can also send alerts when vendors exceed predefined thresholds, enabling prompt corrective actions, saving time, and ensuring consistent data collection and analysis.
Tailoring monitoring efforts
It is essential to customize your monitoring efforts based on the specific risks associated with each vendor and their corresponding risk level. Vendors classified as high-risk, particularly those providing critical services, should be subjected to more frequent and thorough monitoring than those posing minimal risk.
Tailoring your approach in this manner allows for the effective allocation of resources, with a heightened focus on areas that could potentially significantly impact your business operations.
Regular reviews and updates
It is essential to establish a consistent schedule for reviewing your monitoring criteria, processes, and tools' effectiveness. Periodically update your risk assessments to reflect any changes in the vendor's business environment or your company’s risk tolerance, including implementing new tools and techniques for effective vendor monitoring.
This practice will ensure that your monitoring efforts remain relevant to the current industry standard and aligned with your organization’s unique needs and challenges.
Collaboration and communication
Foster a culture of strong collaboration and transparent communication among all parties involved in vendor management. Vendor management encompasses the procurement department, IT, compliance teams, and business units directly interacting with vendors.
Regular face-to-face meetings, video conferences, and shared digital platforms can play a pivotal role in ensuring everyone is well-informed about the monitoring standards and any issues the team has identified. This proactive approach will facilitate a coordinated and efficient response to any challenges.
UpGuard helps organizations collaborate and communicate with their vendors through our vendor collaboration streamlining services.
Compliance and reporting
Make sure you design your continuous monitoring activities to align with the specific regulations and industry standards applicable to your organization. Establish robust VRM reporting mechanisms that offer detailed insights and thorough documentation to substantiate compliance claims.
These measures are essential for successfully navigating regulatory audits and fortifying your organization's standing during contract negotiations or when renewing agreements with vendors.
Take advantage of always-on vendor management with UpGuard
UpGuard Vendor Risk is a TPRM platform designed to automate and streamline an organization’s third-party risk management program. By leveraging technology to simplify the often complex and time-consuming task of evaluating vendor risks, UpGuard Vendor Risk helps organizations efficiently assess, monitor, and mitigate cyber risks associated with their vendors and suppliers.
Additional Vendor Risk features include:
- Customizable templates: UpGuard provides customizable questionnaire templates that users can tailor to meet specific industry standards, regulatory requirements, and organizational risk profiles.
- Bulk distribution and tracking: Vendor Risk enables the distribution of questionnaires to multiple vendors simultaneously and tracks the progress of each questionnaire, sending reminders and updates as necessary.
- Centralized vendor information: UpGuard centralizes all vendor information, including questionnaire responses, in a single platform, making it easier for organizations to access, review, and analyze vendor data.
- Automated risk scoring: UpGuard automatically scores vendors based on their questionnaire responses and other relevant data, which helps organizations quickly assess vendor risk levels and prioritize follow-up actions.
- Continuous monitoring: Vendor Risk monitors vendors’ cybersecurity postures and alerts users to changes or emerging vulnerabilities. Real-time visibility into vendor risks helps organizations respond swiftly to potential threats before they become incidents.
- Compliance management: UpGuard Vendor Risk helps vendors reach regulatory compliance with relevant regulations and standards (like GDPR, HIPAA, and SOC 2), tracking vendors’ certification statuses and identifying gaps or issues that need addressing.
- Collaborative features: Vendor Risk facilitates collaboration between internal teams and vendors, enabling seamless communication and efficiently resolving identified issues or risks.
- Comprehensive reporting: UpGuard provides detailed reports and dashboards that offer insights into the organization’s overall vendor risk landscape, which security teams can use for internal risk management purposes and to demonstrate compliance to stakeholders, auditors, and regulators.
